BERRYVILLE — A local political organizer has filed a report with the Clarke County Sheriff’s Office saying she received a threatening email early Monday morning.

Lisa Holliday organizes for Indivisible Winchester Virginia (IWV), a chapter of a national movement dedicated to opposing the agenda of Republican President Donald Trump and his administration. The group is made up of Republicans, Democrats and independents.

Holliday, who lives near Boyce, contacted the Sheriff’s Office on Monday about an anonymous email she said she received that calls Indivisible Winchester Virginia “inappropriate, unjustified and un-American.”

The email further states, “My group of moderate Republicans is putting you on notice that we will not stand for this type of movement in the Winchester/Frederick County Community.”

The message was sent at about 4:20 a.m. from the address using the name Gertrude Scotch. The “n” at the end of “opposition” is missing from the email address.

Making heavy use of bold text, capitalization and strings of exclamation points, the email claims that action against the “left-wing radicals” is potentially forthcoming.

“Our group, which we don’t seek to make public, will deal very privately with any radicals who publicly seek to delegitimize, denigrate, malign, defame, slander, smear, or vilify our President,” the email states. “Our message to anyone who seeks to discredit the impeccable reputation and the unwavering efforts of President Trump will be met with the consequences deemed appropriate by our membership. ... You and others like you are only poking a hornet’s nest and believe me aggravation will only be tolerated so long before you are stung.

“This is all the notice you will receive. You should take everything I said to heart because if you elect to ignore what I have said there will be a price to pay which I’m quite sure you will regret.”

The email tells Holliday not to reply.

“Don’t bother replying because I have no desire to hear anymore of your blathering chin music. The email address I am sending this from will be deleted to prevent you from replying so don’t waste your time.”

The email also includes a series of insults regarding the “thousands of fat women” who participated in various women’s marches around the country on Jan. 21. Various news sources have estimated that between 2 million and 3.5 million people demonstrated on that date in support of women’s rights and in opposition to Trump around the United States. In Winchester, about 1,300 people gathered downtown.

“Notwithstanding the health benefits of getting these women to march, the event I suspect created millions of dollars in profits for those vendors selling materials to create signage and those selling food and drink,” the email states. “You and your group of left wing radicals should recognize from this successful event that our President is brilliant based on all the benefits this march led to. Women’s health and business profits[!]”

Clarke County Sheriff Tony Roper confirmed Monday that a report had been made regarding the email and was under investigation by his office.

“It’s illegal to make threats,” Roper said.

The person who sent the email may have committed a crime in doing so, he said. In order for prosecution to occur, the county commonwealth’s attorney would have to decide to bring charges based on the results of the police investigation.

Roper declined to comment further.

According to the Code of Virginia, issuing a threat of death or bodily harm is a Class 6 felony, which carries with it a penalty of one to five years in prison. Steeper penalties exist for threats of terrorism.

The email does not threaten any specific action.

Holliday said she considers the email a threat of violence, but won’t be deterred from organizing.

“... [O]ne of the many things that makes America great already is our right as individuals to make our views known,” she said in a Monday email. “That is what the system is designed for, and we [at IWV] peacefully, but without apology, let our views be known to our elected officials.”

She wrote that the group is taking the email “very seriously, and law enforcement and attorneys are involved. ... We are bringing our collective resources together to identify, and expose the person or persons who sent this letter.”

She said she may be in contact with the Frederick County Sheriff’s office to ask that a deputy be sent to the next Indivisible Winchester Virginia meeting.

Indivisible Winchester Virginia held its first meeting Feb. 1. About 100 people attended.

The group’s plan is to continue meeting every two weeks.


Indivisible Winchester Virginia has a group page on Facebook,

— Contact Onofrio Castiglia at

(10) comments


We have massive resources now tracking down the sender. They will be exposed.


The fact that the Indivisible group is public and the sender of the email will not go public speaks volumes. If you're peaceful, and you're just standing up for your beliefs, then what's the problem? That's Constitution 101. The statement that the email sender's group 'will not tolerate' the Indivisible group, along with the other vague threats, shows where potential violence lies.


It saddens, rather than frightens me, to see this hatred and bullying behavior. I sincerely hope that the email sender is not from our area, because I believe the best of people in Winchester/Clarke and that neighbors whose beliefs differ from ours would not condone this type of behavior. I admit, it's difficult to not feel targeted, or wonder who is against us, as we participate in community events, go to the grocery store, take our kids to the playground, and walk around the neighborhood. But I won't be pushed into distrust and hatred and will continue to foster communication and friendship with those whose beliefs differ from mine, so that we might learn from each other. Nice try, hateful letter writer, but you won't frighten us into silence.


It is critical that citizen groups be able to express their wished freely and communicate to lawmakers. Winchester Indivisible is a peaceful group of concerned citizens from all parties. The threat against them is disturbing. So glad law enforcement are involved. We all need to be vigilant and protect the right of our fellow citizens to take peaceful action.


Time to break out the internet forensics, find this scum bag and frog march him/her to a jail cell.


Look at Vogel's open internet setup first, you might find something!


We Are Indivisible!


Dissent is the most American thing there is - after all, what was the Boston Tea Party but a demonstration of dissatisfaction with government? Making vague threats toward people whose views are different from your own is one of the most craven things I can think of. But LOLing at the thought of Mr. Trump's reputation being impeccable. Maybe switch from making threats to a career in comedy.

Mark Anderson

What cowards hide behind anonymity to make threats of violence against those with differing political ideologies. Crawl back under your rock, we will not accept intimidation as our new normal.


Yes, cowardly radicals accusing peaceful opposition volunteers of radicalism. Interesting. Since when is activism is not allowed in this country?

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.