In the July 6, 2019, edition of The Star, the Opinion Editor, Mr. Adrian O’Connor, decries the defenestration of two of the nation’s most revered founding fathers, Messrs. Washington and Jefferson, at the hands of “Progressives” for having been slaveowners. Mr. O’Connor all but excuses Washington and Jefferson’s behavior by the simple expedient of stating they were creatures of their time and place. The plantation system in the antibellum South relied upon slavery to sustain itself; both Washington and Jefferson owned plantations; both Washington and Jefferson were creatures of their time and place; hence both Washington and Jefferson can be excused for owning slaves. There is, of course a certain logic to this admittedly convoluted syllogism.

There can be no question but that slavery in the South as it existed during the lifetime of those two men was brutal and degrading. There can be no question but that anyone who observed slavery at that time, or at any prior point in time, including slaveowners, non-slaveowners, abolitionists, and everyone else, knew slavery was a great moral wrong and a great crime against humanity. Thus, is it not reasonable to assume that Washington and Jefferson realized slavery was inherently evil? Would that not mean that they were guilty of perpetuating an evil that existed only so they and other slaveholders could profit from the institution? Is their sin not greater since they were exceptionally influential?

Consequently, is it is such a far-fetched notion to expect that these men, even given the time and place in which they lived, should have realized the inherent evil of this institution; an evil that was “self-evident.” One might be forgiven for wondering why it took the cataclysm of the Civil War to end the practice? What justification could slaveowners conjure up to perpetuate this evil? Why the exploitation of unrequited labor for “profit”, of course! (Which is not to say that slaves were not exploited for other purposes.)

I am cognizant of the fact that to criticize men like Washington and Jefferson by judging them in hindsight is perilous. In doing so, we invite future generations to rain opprobrium on ourselves for conduct which we currently accept as the norm, or even innocuous, but which those future generations may see as wholly deplorable. How much more then do we open ourselves for condemnation for behavior which is patently odious, even to us in this time and place. But isn’t that entirely fair and appropriate? Man continues to evolve and civilizations continue to refine, hopefully for the better. Why should we living today not expect to be criticized by future generations for our mistakes, particularly those we are aware of and are capable of correcting.

Take for example, our stewardship of the Planet Earth. The vast majority of humankind realize that we are destroying the only home we have, making it unfit for all living things. However, we continue to degrade the Earth because large numbers of people oppose taking reasonable action to correct the trend. Why? Because corrective action will impact the margin of profit on investment. Should we not be judged harshly by future generations if we fail to act to save the planet? Surely we will. I doubt that future generations will excuse our crime against not only humanity but all living things because we were creatures of our time.

Michael A. Rea is a resident of Winchester.

(4) comments

DaWholeTruth

In the mid-1700s, slavery was a worldwide phenomenon. It did not I repeat, not originate in the United States. The Abolitionist Movement had its beginnings in 1830. A full 60 plus years after Washington and Jefferson had owned slaves. Was owning slaves egregiously wrong by the standards of the mid-1700s? No, simply stated, it was not. It was an accepted practice in most of the colonies at that time. The Abolitionist Movement came along in the 1830s, gained momentum and resulted in the Civil War in the 1860s where 600000 Plus Americans gave their lives to settle that argument, a mighty steep price to pay. Yet people today are holding our founding fathers to today's standards, such as they are, and belittling everything they did to make this nation what it is today by rewriting a besmirched and belittled history. What a twisted shame!

Eredmon

I applaud Mr. Rea for admitting to us in his forum that all of us can/will be judged by future generations. According to his AOC, in 12 years there will be no future generation. So-called environmentalists like Mr. Gore might go a bit farther in convincing people if they lived the lifestyle that they try to impose on others. There is a happy medium that both sides of this issue should be seeking, one that we can live with today and tomorrow. And one last word about the incredible people who helped to found this nation, the overwhelming good that they achieved should be mentioned in the same breath where we cite that they were also human with frailties that now should be forgiven rather than tearing down the foundation of our country for other reasons. We cannot change the past, but should always learn from it.

Rattler

Slavery???. What about the business that hire illegals. Most live on property in what alot of people would consider deplorable conditions make little for wages. Just like with slavery, one wants to focus on the bad. Remember alot of slaves chose to stay with their owners. Yes slavery was WRONG, they were sold by their own people just like the coyotes being paid to bring their own people to America illegally to work, sex traffic ,etc. Unfortunately doesnt seen like alot was learned from the past. Stop illegal immigration now or we will will repeat the past.

hagansan

My favorite Tom Toro cartoon shows a group of climate refugees gathered in the shadow of a ruined city. A man in a tattered business suit says, "Yes the planet got destroyed. But for a beautiful moment in time we created a lot of value for shareholders."

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.