The end of the year is just around the corner, and the stalemate between Anthem and Valley Health is, regrettably, still unresolved. Despite the careful PR spin and consistent messaging coming from Valley Health, I remain unconvinced that Anthem is the problem in this stalemate.

Valley Health wants us to believe Anthem is unfair; that Valley Health is under-compensated by the health insurance company, and that this is the root of the stalemate. I find this hard to believe when the Valley Health Fitness Center recently announced to its members that it is spending $2.8 million to expand and renovate the gym. It’s already the best gym in the area; it’s more than adequate and exceeds all my expectations.

We don’t need a brand-new, 6,200 square-foot functional training space — there is already more than enough workout space and plenty of equipment of every imaginable type. We don’t need to completely remodel all men’s and women’s locker rooms — they’re excellent as they are; the best I’ve ever seen in a gym. And we definitely don’t need to remodel the entryway vestibule by bumping it out six extra feet and adding automatic sliding doors — the current doors are beautiful and already open automatically.

Valley Health refuses to budge in its negotiations with Anthem to protect the insurance benefits of so many in Winchester, and yet it’s happy to spend $2.8 million on unnecessary fitness center renovations? Obviously, Valley Health is not hurting for money, despite its efforts to “fight” for payments that are up to current standards of living (the reason it gives for not resolving its conflict with Anthem). If its staff is suffering under unfair compensation from Anthem, why not invest that $2.8 million in its own people? I am more than happy to continue enjoying the excellent fitness center facilities as they are. We don’t NEED these changes. Valley Health has revealed the truth about these negotiations: it doesn’t care if patients lose their Anthem health insurance plans if it means more cash lining its own pockets. I would much rather keep my Anthem health insurance than add six more feet to the fitness center vestibule, and I would’ve gladly told Valley Health this, had they cared enough about the people its serves to ask us directly.

Valley Health is trying to make it look like it is the victim in this dispute, but the real victims are the patients who are going to lose their Anthem coverage because of the greed of Valley Health administrators. If Valley Health wanted us to buy its PR spin, it shouldn’t have approved a huge remodeling budget before this conflict was resolved. Now the truth is staring us in the face: this conflict could be quickly resolved if Valley Health would yield to Anthem and put its patients’ needs first.

Elisabeth Townsend is a Winchester resident.

(5) comments


Anthem stock has averaged a nearly 18% gain every single year since the millennium. If you bought at $14.75 in the year 2000 you could sell at $312.80 today. Sweet!!!


The alarm was sounded on Valley Health back in 2009 and today is 2020 ...



Valley Health has plenty of money. They simply suffer from envy of Anthem, who has more money. Negotiating for more is fine. It’s their right to do so. But putting policyholders in the middle is BS. Mark Nantz has damaged people and families in Winchester and is known word-of-mouth in a negative way. If he doesn’t work this out in the next week, his reputation will be cemented. And no amount of charitable “donations” will change that. Valley Health is destroying the feeling of community and togetherness during the Covid pandemic and the holiday season.


Here's Mark Nantz' opportunity to show what a kind, tolerant gentleman he is by ignoring your false and libelous comments.


Ms. Townsend, I agree with you wholeheartedly. I have stated time and time again about how the hospital overcharges. Thank you for your report.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.