Second Amendment

Standing before a capacity crowd that spilled over into Rouss City Hall's lobby, Sylvia White (left) of Winchester asks members of Winchester's City Council on Tuesday to declare the city a sanctuary for the Second Amendment right to bear firearms. "A firearm is a force equalizer," White said.

WINCHESTER — More than 100 people crammed into City Council chambers and spilled into the lobby of Rouss City Hall on Tuesday to express their support for gun ownership.

"The right to possess this tool is given to me by both the U.S. and Virginia constitutions," said Frederick County resident Scott Wagner, who, like the majority of audience members in the gallery, wore an orange sticker that stated, "Guns Save Lives."

A push to preserve Americans' Second Amendment right to bear firearms has been occurring in recent weeks across Virginia, with advocates asking municipalities to declare themselves sanctuaries from stricter gun laws that are expected to be voted on by the state General Assembly when it convenes next month.

The Frederick County Board of Supervisors was expected to adopt a resolution Wednesday night opposing any law that infringes on the Second Amendment. The governing bodies of Winchester and Clarke County have not indicated if they plan to follow Frederick County's example.

City resident and Army veteran Brandon Angel rallied supporters of the Second Amendment to attend Tuesday night's City Council meeting.

"Virginia does not want these law passed; instead, it is the suburbs of [Washington] D.C.," Angel said as the crowd applauded. "Mental health is the biggest problem in this country, and gangs [are] a close second."

Frederick County resident Cory O'Donnell said the proposed gun laws could lead to government confiscation of legally owned firearms and munitions.

"All members of this council swore an oath to defend the constitution," O'Donnell told City Council.

After hearing from eight people who oppose Virginia's efforts to strengthen gun laws, Mayor David Smith closed the public comment portion of Tuesday's council meeting and did not ask if anyone else in the audience wished to speak.

Afterward, no one on City Council mentioned the Second Amendment sanctuary proposal, and there were no indications that Winchester would consider adopting a resolution similar to the one in Frederick County.

Also at Tuesday night's meeting and work session, City Council:

  • Unanimously approved a conditional-use permit to allow O’Reilly Auto Parts to build a store with a slightly pitched roof at 603 Cedar Creek Grade, located in one of Winchester’s corridor-enhancement districts.
  • Unanimously approved a one-year extension of a partial tax exemption for Peyton Street Properties LLC regarding a property it is renovating at 6 W. Cecil St.
  • Unanimously agreed to forward a proposed public/private partnership with Shenandoah University that would allow the college to manage and make improvements to the baseball and softball fields in Jim Barnett Park.
  • Unanimously approved modifications to Winchester’s vacation, holiday and sick leave policies for municipal employees. The vacation and sick leave revisions will not apply to the city's Fire and Rescue Department because its staff works more hours and accrues leave at a different rate than other city employees.
  • Voted 8-1 to adopt Winchester's legislative priorities for the 2020 Virginia General Assembly session. Councilor Les Veach opposed the measure due to his opposition to the city's desire to establish a new grievance procedure for employees.
  • Unanimously approved an ordinance clarifying that property owners are required to pay water and sewer availability fees before the city issues a building permit.
  • Received the findings of an annual audit of the city's comprehensive financial report. Accountant John Aldridge of Partner, Brown, Edwards and Co. LLP said Winchester is in very good economic health.
  • Heard a presentation on the duties and responsibilities of the Frederick-Winchester Service Authority.
  • Unanimously agreed to forward the proposed appointment of Ronald Mislowsky to a three-year term on the Frederick-Winchester Service Authority, ending Jan. 13, 2023.
  • Unanimously agreed to forward the proposed reappointments of Elizabeth Minor and Kimberly Sowers to three-year terms on the Old Town Advancement Commission, ending Jan. 13, 2023, and Mark Loring to a four-year term on the Winchester Planning Commission, ending Jan. 13, 2024.
  • Met in executive session for 40 minutes to discuss litigation involving Afresh Church and the scope of the city's legal representation. No action was taken following the closed-door discussions.

Attending Tuesday night’s City Council meeting and work session in Rouss City Hall were Mayor and council President David Smith, Vice Mayor John Hill, Vice President Evan Clark and councilors Kim Herbstritt, John Willingham, Bill Wiley, Corey Sullivan, Judy McKiernan and Les Veach.

— Contact Brian Brehm at

(11) comments


The part liberals miss...NOT UP FOR A VOTE. Civil Rights arent for leftists and their noisy mob to vote on...OR we can vote on your perversities. See how it works

Don Specht

Is liberal tyranny as bad as conservative tryanny?


I wonder if this kind of response would be present if we were talking about establishing public transportation to one of the nation's best community colleges, LFCC. The best way to ensure freedom is through education. Why is there such a high level of anxiety associated with an duly elected, term limited, imaginary, despotic leader that will violate the Constitution of the United States and somehow deny your rights? Come on folks, think!!! If we could find a way to establish a public transportation system to our community college, we could help students who struggle to take advantage of the opportunities available at this very fine institution. Let that sink in.


Notice the Star chose to ignore last nights Frederick County Board meeting where THOUSANDS of citizens came to defy liberal tyranny. Winchester is now a liberal bastion surrounded by Patriots who refuse to have their rights stolen.


how did they ignore it when they posted an article about it? lol. dEfY LiBerAl tYraNNy!


The article is about winchester city. Not frederick county. Lol

Steve Cunningham

The Star's printed edition is always a day behind since they do not print the paper locally any longer. Frederick County's 2nd Amendment story will be in tomorrow's edition


Actually, the WStar came out with the article last night on the Frederick County meeting and the count was 1000 people were there.


I was there. And there is no chance it was only 1000 people.


"The right to possess this tool is given to me by both the U.S. and Virginia constitutions," said Frederick County resident Scott Wagner,

Mr. Wagner - I would submit that the constitutions to which you refer do not "give" you any rights at all. Our rights are endowed by our creator and are guaranteed by the constitutions of the United States and the state of Virginia. It may sound like I am picking nits, but this is a very important distinction and we should never infer that it is the government from which we derive our rights.


lilbertyspirit but WE are the government. We the People. It was the Founders, All People, who wrote our godless Constitution and the Bill of Rights on which we depend for those rights. Our ancestors created our Rights and it is up to us to defend them and demand them from each other and the collective force of the government which is made up of us and elected by us. We the People are the creators and guarantors of our Rights.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.