WINCHESTER — As a new principal is sought for Handley High School, Winchester Public Schools Superintendent Jason Van Heukelum shared a sobering 24-page review of the school at Tuesday night’s School Board meeting.

The report shows, among other things, that Handley could jeopardize its full state accreditation status if it continues to have high dropout and chronic absenteeism rates.

Accreditation is based on standardized test scores, graduation rates and absenteeism rates.

Van Heukelum shared the report’s findings following calls from the public for more transparency from school officials amid administrative upheaval at Handley. Principal Mike Dufrene, who has been Handley’s principal for the past five years, recently announced he was leaving at the end of the current school year to become principal at Hampshire High School in Romney, West Virginia. His announcement came on the heels of rumors that his contract at Handley wasn’t being renewed, which sparked an outcry from many parent and student supporters.

What happened with Dufrene’s contract remains unclear — neither the board nor Van Heukelum would comment about it Tuesday night — but Van Heukelum acknowledged the backlash the he and the board have received over it.

“It’s no secret that the last three weeks have been somewhat tumultuous for our community,” Van Heukelum said. “Certainly the School Board has taken a lot of heat or speculation regarding Mr. Dufrene and his exit from Handley High School.”

The report Van Heukelum presented Tuesday night was compiled by various department heads in the school division’s Central Administrative Office. Reports of this nature are typically generated as part of the principal recruitment process and shared within the division, but not made public. However, because of comments made by members of the public at a recent School Board meeting about the need for more transparency from city school officials, the board asked Van Heukelum to share the report with the community.

“We’re happy to do that,” Van Heukelum said.

Some of the report’s findings show:

Handley’s state Standards of Learning (SOL) average scores have dropped four to nine points in reading, writing, history and science over the past three years. However, the average math SOL scores have improved by seven points over the same time period.

Chronic absenteeism has been a consistent problem at Handley for the past six years, with 19.6% to 24.19% of the school’s approximately 1,300 students missing at least 18 days or 10% of the 180-day school year.

The dropout rate increased from 2.43% for the Class of 2015 to 7.1% for the Class of 2019, reaching level 2 accreditation status. If a school has level 2 or level 3 status for four consecutive years, the school will receive an “Accredited with Conditions” status.

Handley’s graduation and completion index dropped 4 points within the past five years from 95.2 points to 91.4 points. But even the lower score is still considered a level 1 status for accreditation, which is the best that can be earned.

Handley is currently fully accredited, and accreditation waivers have been issued for 2020 to public schools across the state because of the coronavirus pandemic

The report also contained data from several student and staff surveys. One survey administered in February by the Department of Criminal Justice Services indicates that 84% of students who responded said “I like this school” and that “teachers and adults treat students with respect.” However, in the same survey, only 52% of teachers said “I feel physically safe at this school” and only 36% of Handley staffers said they trust one another.

“This one hurts my heart a little bit,” Van Heukelum said about the survey’s findings on teachers feeling safe at school. “To think that 48% or almost half of our teachers would not agree to that is something that, you know, I don’t want any teacher in our school division to feel. That’s well below the state average.”

School Board member Karen Holman noted there’s a disconnect in the findings, with most students saying they feel respected by teachers but nearly half of teachers saying they don’t feel safe or respected by students.

Van Heukelum agreed, adding that it’s up to Handley’s next principal to dig into the data and analyze it.

In another survey conducted by Winchester Public Schools through Panorama, with responses from 962 students and 111 teachers, only 31% of students reported that they felt a sense of belonging at Handley.

Another survey completed by the Department of Criminal Justice Services found that 66% of Handley students said they are treated fairly regardless of race or ethnicity while 44% of respondents said students are teased or put down because of their race or ethnicity.

The report Van Heukelum shared also noted a “disproportionate discipline rate of special education, African American and multi-racial students” across all schools in Winchester Public Schools, including Handley, which is the city’s only high school.

“In 2019, the African American suspension rate was almost three times the population and the multi-racial suspension rate was almost four times the population,” the report said, referencing suspension data collected by the Virginia Department of Education.

“How is this not a failure of all of us?” School Board member Elyus Wallace asked. “Somebody fell asleep at the wheel.”

Van Heukelum said there is shared ownership of the findings, including himself. Van Heukelum has been the superintendent of the division since 2016.

“Certainly, this is my data too, and I don’t shy away from that,” Van Heukelum said. “That is certainly a part of my evaluation [by the School Board], as it should be.”

At the beginning of Tuesday night’s meeting, School Board Chairwoman Allyson Pate said she and the board were appreciative of the “time and energy” that came from the public comments expressed about Dufrene and his tenure at Handley.

“We heard the pain and anguish expressed so passionately. We heard the frustration and questioning as to how we perform our duties as a board. We heard your hopes and expectations for our children and our community,” Pate said. “But throughout I also heard that we have a common goal. That goal being doing what best meets the needs of Winchester Public Schools today and tomorrow. Now and in the future.”

A job posting for Handley’s next principal was posted by the school division last week.

Attending Tuesday night’s business meeting held virtually from the Central Administrative Office at 12 N. Washington St. were Winchester Superintendent Jason Van Heukelum, School Board Chairwoman Allyson Pate, School Board Vice Chairwoman Marie Imoh and board members Bryan Pearce-Gonzales, Richard Bell, Karen Holman, Mike Birchenough, Elyus Wallace and Erica Truban. The meeting was publicly held through Zoom.

— Contact Anna Merod at

(24) comments

The Pibbster

This article is very misleading, IMHO.

- Mike Dufrene was given 3 options ... resign, take a position at Central Office or take an asst. principal job at elementary school

- Article leads readers to believe he left because things are bad

- What were #'s before Mike Dufrene became principal?

- WPS is basically an inner school system with the diversity ... is the Superintendent and school board just learning this?

- The report ... are there any areas that is going to cause Handley to lose its accreditation right now?

- With what is coming now from Daniel Morgan ... they need a Mike Dufrene at Handley

Wise man once told me ... Milburn ... paper lay still they can write anything on it!


Where can we see the referenced report on Handley? It's not on the BoardDocs site.


@CTJINVAOn the Agenda from the Tues pm meeting on Board Docs there are 4 attachments under the agenda item re:Handley Principal click on those.. they are results of the surveys. Also they are available for viewing on the VA Dept Of Ed website somewhere.. as they are public results not just for the meeting this past week!


You children can’t even agree to disagree without name calling. Isn’t this supposed to be about the real children? You know, the ones in high school?!? Stop pointing fingers, it all starts at the top. Now figure it out!


The decline of the family unit is probably the most telling statistic in this case. Strong families help provide strong communities.


That didn't begin in the last 3 years.


It's time for people in Wincehster to take notice that the school administration has fallen asleep at the wheel. Not necessarily Dufrene, but the central office and the school board.

We worked hard to get an elected school board on the ballot and this year Winchester will have its first school board election in decades. Who is going to step up?


In 2018 Winchester City had greater than 40% of the families with children as being single-parent families. Children growing up in single-parent families typically do not have the same economic or human resources available as those growing up in two-parent families. Compared with children in married-couple families, children raised in single-parent households are more likely to drop out of school and face other negative consequences including scoring lower on standardized tests. This data is available to those who choose to look it up and is conveniently left out of the school board's metrics.

As stated in the article 84% of the students like the school and feel the teachers treat the students with respect and 66% feel they are treated fairly regardless of race or ethnicity. Based on the student's own responses it seems to me that those that were disciplined were not done unjustly as inferred by Van Heukelum and one of the School Board members.

VanHeukelum further acknowledges that it will up to Handley's next principal to dig into the data and analyze it. I disagree and School Board member Wallace I think said it best. "Somebody fell asleep at the wheel". Those steering the wheel are the Superintendant and the School Board. Under these same circumstances, the next principal will suffer the same fate.


Absolutely! It starts at the top.


Do whatever is necessary to make Handley the number one school in the state. Period.


Start by making free public education a privilege instead of a right if you can't behave like a civilized human being.


Perhaps you'd like to read this article. It may help explain why public education is a right (an unenumerated one but still a right).


So you want to repeal FARE?


I don't know what FARE is. Do you mean FAPE? Also, my post was informative only. I haven't expressed an opinion either way on this issue.


@jmapplin, yes, I meant FAPE. Stupid autocorrect. My comment was for Conservative, not you. Conservative is constantly calling for the abolition of public schools. Makes me wonder who he is.


Anything? 20% more property tax because money cures everything right?

Doc Samson

When students face little more than constant lecturing for out of control behaviors, chronic absenteeism, etc., when the blame gets laid on teachers, social workers. or school administrators who want to impose some sense of order, when discipline is looked at as a racial issue, when basic expectations are turned into debatable talking points, things can go nowhere but down. This is true in school systems across the country and everyone has a share of the blame, but where does the buck stop? Who is ultimately responsible for implementing these ridiculous policies and enforcing them? Parents who don't? Judges who excuse time and time again or blame everyone but the student/parent? Admin who have no conception of the difference between theory and reality? So many questions...


What a crock of BS. This was obviously created to make Dufrene look bad. Those who know him know differently. Van Huckster is just trying to keep his cushy job. And those disciplinary "race" statistics?? Please. If a kid acts up, they need to be disciplined. Skin color doesn't matter, that's got nothing to do with behavior issues.


Racist POV. You overlooked the word 'disproportionate'.

Doc Samson

Well, then, which race do we use as the discipline template that cannot be exceeded by other races? Asian? Native American? Hispanic? He literally paraphrased MLK by saying that skin color doesn't matter, behavior does. But, of course, he's racist... [rolleyes] Unless I'm somehow misinterpreting your comment...


Fools always cry "RACISM" when they have no argument to stand on.


But I thought you hated Handley for letting a convicted sex offender roam the halls? Now you're made because racial profiling is making the school look bad?

This must be why you hide your identity... #coward

Doc Samson

Maybe he doesn't want to risk getting doxxed by the Left? You know it's a favorite tactic your side uses to address those they disagree with, right? #weird/obsession/with/names/but/only/for/conservatives


Awwww poor babies. Don't want to be held accountable for disgusting speech? Probably shouldn't be doing it.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.
Stay on topic. The comment section is for remarks specifically regarding the article or opinion piece. It is not a forum to attack someone with another perspective. If you disagree with a commenter, civilly provide your reasons why. Comments will be sent to a moderator for approval or denial before they are posted.